You know everything possible about signal integrity, EMC, and manufacturing, but the PCB stackup design still seems to come up as a gotcha before PCB manufacturing. PCB stackups are not that complex, and yet even pro designers with plenty of experience might have to make changes before manufacturing. There are multiple reasons for this, such as materials availability, sudden cost changes, or processing constraints with the fab vendor.
Regardless of why a PCB stackup needs to be changed, there are some tips designers can follow which can help prevent changes before going to fabrication. At minimum, the changes might only involve a substitution request based on IPC slash sheets. Keep reading to see these pro tips and understand what questions to ask your fabricator.
If you don't do the PCB stackup right, you won't know you have a problem until it's time to manufacture it. After building many PCBs, I've found that there are several areas relating to stackup design where manufacturers have requested changes:
Fortunately, there are some easy ways to get around these mistakes and avoid stackup changes before manufacturing.
If your design requires very specific materials and you have an initial stackup in mind, it never hurts to send your PCB fabrication company an email about your proposed materials and stackup. I continue to be surprised by the number of designers that will not do this when they have a stackup materials requirement.
While it helps to have an ideal stackup in mind or even a complete stackup design, this is not required before you talk to a fabricator. For example, if you know that you will need an advanced or less common material in your PCB stackup, you can ask the fabrication house for their lead time, or if they stock a specific material in-house. Even if they don't stock the material, they might offer a suitable alternative that works the same or better in your timeline.
PCB fabricators offer standard stackups as a tool for quickly getting a board into production. There are plenty of designs that don't have hard material requirements, only the layer count and the total PCB thickness matter. When this is the case, a standard stackup from the PCB fabricator can be used. This offers two big advantages:
Fabricators often provide material names and datasheets for the materials used in their standard stackups, and this allows designers to take a controlled dielectric approach for impedance-controlled designs. In other words, you can use the dielectric data and create your own transmission line designs without requiring the fabricator’s input. However, standard stackups also admit a controlled impedance approach, where the manufacturer uses their data to verify the impedance values of specific nets in your design.
Some fabrication companies will also offer standardized advanced stackups, such as flex or rigid-flex, high voltage, RF, and even HDI. Make sure to check with the fabrication vendor to see their service offerings.
You might think using heavy copper or multiple lamination/plating cycles makes you a pro designer, but the real skill comes from understanding the DFM constraints that come with heavier copper.
Clearances: Plating with heavier copper requires larger spacing between copper features to allow for copper growth during the plating process. This means that, even though your base PCB stackup materials will start with 0.5 oz. or 1 oz. copper, you will need to allow for larger clearances based on fully plated copper weight.
Through-hole pads and annular rings: Heavier copper can increase drill drift in mechanical drilling as the drill is pushed through the copper pads on each layer. This will require increasing the pad sizes to allow for larger annular rings on plated through-holes.
Via aspect ratio: Mechanically-drilled via aspect ratios can be limited when copper weight is heavier, either due to the usage of higher copper weight or due to multiple copper plating cycles with sub-laminations. This may require increasing the drill diameter in order to accommodate heavier copper.
Manufacturers can provide the clearance requirement for heavier copper. This will typically be some base clearance value plus another factor related to the plated copper thickness. If the clearance requirements are not given on the manufacturer’s website, email the manufacturer for a capabilities statement.
A useful tool for understanding PCB material compatibility in stackup fabrication is an IPC slash sheet. The slash sheet number for a material identifies its compatibility with other commercially-available materials. It is therefore common in PCB stackups that do not have a dielectric constant or impedance requirement to specify a slash sheet for the core/prepreg materials in the PCB fabrication notes.
For example, take a look at the slash sheet for FR408HR from Isola. I have circled the IPC-4101 slash sheet numbers in blue. To learn more about slash sheets and to see a table listing compatibility across different slash sheet entries, read this article.
Slash sheets do not perfectly align to specific capabilities or material properties, but they do align with processing. If you specify a slash sheet for a material, but you need to have some other specification met by the materials (for example, high-voltage reliability), then you should specify this in the fabrication notes or select a commercial material that meets the specifications.
Whether you need to build reliable power electronics or advanced digital systems, use Altium’s complete set of PCB design features and world-class CAD tools. Altium provides the world’s premier electronic product development platform, complete with the industry’s best PCB design tools and cross-disciplinary collaboration features for advanced design teams. Contact an expert at Altium today!