Free Trials

Download a free trial to find out which Altium software best suits your needs

How to Buy

Contact your local sales office to get started on improving your design environment

Downloads

Download the latest in PCB design and EDA software

  • PCB DESIGN SOFTWARE
  • Altium Designer

    Complete Environment for Schematic + Layout

  • CircuitStudio

    Entry Level, Professional PCB Design Tool

  • CircuitMaker

    Community Based PCB Design Tool

  • NEXUS

    Agile PCB Design For Teams

  • CLOUD PLATFORM
  • Altium 365

    Connecting PCB Design to the Manufacturing Floor

  • COMPONENT MANAGEMENT
  • Altium Concord Pro

    Complete Solution for Library Management

  • Octopart

    Extensive, Easy-to-Use Component Database

  • PRODUCT EXTENSIONS
  • PDN Analyzer

    Natural and Effortless Power Distribution Network Analysis

  • See All Extensions
  • EMBEDDED
  • TASKING

    World-Renowned Technology for Embedded Systems Development

  • TRAININGS
  • Live Courses

    Learn best practices with instructional training available worldwide

  • On-Demand Courses

    Gain comprehensive knowledge without leaving your home or office

  • ONLINE VIEWER
  • Altium 365 Viewer

    View & Share electronic designs in your browser

  • Altium Designer 20

    The most powerful, modern and easy-to-use PCB design tool for professional use

    ALTIUMLIVE

    Annual PCB Design Summit

    • Forum

      Where Altium users and enthusiasts can interact with each other

    • Blog

      Our blog about things that interest us and hopefully you too

    • Ideas

      Submit ideas and vote for new features you want in Altium tools

    • Bug Crunch

      Help make the software better by submitting bugs and voting on what's important

    • Wall

      A stream of events on AltiumLive you follow by participating in or subscribing to

    • Beta Program

      Information about participating in our Beta program and getting early access to Altium tools

    All Resources

    Explore the latest content from blog posts to social media and technical white papers gathered together for your convenience

    Downloads

    Take a look at what download options are available to best suit your needs

    How to Buy

    Contact your local sales office to get started improving your design environment

    • Documentation

      The documentation area is where you can find extensive, versioned information about our software online, for free.

    • Training & Events

      View the schedule and register for training events all around the world and online

    • Design Content

      Browse our vast library of free design content including components, templates and reference designs

    • Webinars

      Attend a live webinar online or get instant access to our on demand series of webinars

    • Support

      Get your questions answered with our variety of direct support and self-service options

    • Technical Papers

      Stay up to date with the latest technology and industry trends with our complete collection of technical white papers.

    • Video Library

      Quick and to-the-point video tutorials to get you started with Altium Designer

    Rigid Outer-Layers to Reduce Cost

    Tara Dunn
    |  April 22, 2019

    Why is a 4-layer Rigid Flex Less Expensive than 3-layer Rigid Flex? 

    Designing flex and rigid-flex can be tricky. Not only do you need to design for a product that will bend, fold and flex, you are working with different materials and fabrication processes. Plusm it is difficult to clearly communicate how the part should flex in final application. Typically, the goal is to use the most cost-effective stack up that meets both your electrical and mechanical performance needs. Logically, a 3-layer design should be less expensive than 4 layers. However, rigid flex is a funny thing. The following example proves that logic to be incorrect. 

    A specific medical application originally had a rigid, 3- layer, flex design. It had flexible layers on the outside with a rigid layer sandwiched between them. The original intention was to keep the layer count as low as possible to keep costs down..The stack up had a dense component area, supported by the rigid inner-layer. Its flex area needed dynamically flexing with a tight bend radius.  Once the design was completed, it was sent to the fabricator for quotation. Pricing came back higher than expected, but this was one of the first rigid flex designs this company had done, so it was assumed this was the typical price of rigid flex.    

    As this project was going through tooling and set up at the fabricator, the designer was asked if flexible photoimageable solder mask could be used to help define the surface mount pads in the dense component area.  Drilled polyimide coverlay was not able to support the density. This was approved, product was built, shipped and assembled. As the flex was mounted in the unit and powered up, it was quickly failed. Failure analysis showed the traces in the flex tail were cracking in use, causing the failure.  

    Communicating How to Use the Flex in the End Application

    Working with the fabricator, it was obvious that the selected  flexible solder mask was not flexible enough to withstand the end-use flexing requirements.  This is a common issue. Design and fabrication rarely communicate with each other how the end application will use the flex. A a part of the problem is that Gerber files are two dimensional while the end use is three dimensional. Had the fabricator understood the need for dynamically flexing, they would not have recommended the flexible solder mask. 

    After several discussions, they decided to change the flexible solder mask to a polyimide coverlay, bringing us back to the initial issue with the surface mount pad density and definition. As a solution, the fabricator recommended laser drilling the polyimide coverlay. The two parties also discussed changing the fabrication to a button plate rather than a panel plate. Button plating only adds copper to the pad area and plated through-holes. This eliminates electrodeposited copper from the construction, keeping the layers as flexible as possible.  

    The project was again released for fabrication, assembled, installed and tested successfully. Perfect! Right?   

    How did the 3-layer Rigid Flex Become 20% More Expensive than the 4-layer?

    Here is what was going on behind the scenes to fabricate this part number. Flex on the outer layers of a rigid flex construction is not common and in this case was significantly driving up costs. The fabricator to reduce the panel size, and subsequently the number of pieces running per panel, which also drove up the costs. In addition, the button plating process itself adds extra cost. 

    Ultimately, this product was redesigned as a more conventional, 4-layer rigid-flex construction with rigid layers on the outer layers and the flex layers sandwiched between. Those dense component areas could then use a standard solder mask process, eliminating the button plating process. Switching to a standard process also increased the panel size and the number per panel. Even though the raw material costs were higher, the overall cost of the part decreased by 20% with this 4-layer design.  

    Lesson Learned

    First, the initial 3-layer rigid-flex design was ultimately successful, and functioned as needed. There was nothing “wrong” with that design. But, there was a less expensive approach; the rigid flex design. Lesson learned.  

    Could this have been avoided? Maybe. Part of the issue was the learning curve that goes along with new technology, and part of it was communication. I sometimes feel that I have become like a broken record, stuck on the same few words, but my best advice for designers new to rigid- flex is always to work with your fabricator, over-explain what you are trying to accomplish and ask for their advice. They work with the technology every day and are happy to recommend best practices and help avoid introducing unnecessary costs.

    Learn more about flex and rigid-flex PCB assembly in Altium Designer® or if you have more questions? Call an expert at Altium.

    About Author

    About Author

    Tara is a recognized industry expert with more than 20 years of experience working with: PCB engineers, designers, fabricators, sourcing organizations, and printed circuit board users. Her expertise is in flex and rigid-flex, additive technology, and quick-turn projects. She is one of the industry's top resources to get up to speed quickly on a range of subjects through her technical reference site PCBadvisor.com and contributes regularly to industry events as a speaker, writes a column in the magazine PCB007.com, and hosts Geek-a-palooza.com. Her business Omni PCB is known for its same day response and the ability to fulfill projects based on unique specifications: lead time, technology and volume.

    most recent articles

    Back to Home